Advertisement
I finally got round to tasting a whole bunch of high thujone absinthes: Absinthe 330, King of Spirits Gold, and one called Century Absinth. The last two have 100mg thujone. I have long been sceptical of being told that pre-ban absinthe has no thujone / low thujone by the new manufacturers. I have also been sceptical of the science that popped up at exactly the same time as the new era of absinthes started to appear. So i decided to find out for myself.
Are the secondaries, so well known during the Belle Epoque, all romantic nonsense and a big conspiracy by French wine growers? I don't think so.
Some may say that I was setting myself up for a placebo effect (nobody can deny that the mind is a powerful and little understood source of mischief) I do not think this is the case with thujone in alcohol. It could be a herbal speedball as Ted Breaux has suggested, but I am now coinvinced that high thujone levels do play a significant role. I cannot account for the astonishing secondaries. I also had a HG over the summer with a reputed level of about 50-60mg. This was by far and away my favourite, although the Century came a very close second.
What if Dr Niels Arnold's estimates of 260mg in pre-ban were correct? Seems more and more likely that being told by commercial interests that pre-ban was virtually "thujone free" fits nicely with a now rampant commercial imperative.
Keep an open mind, or better if you can afford it (as these high thujone absinthes are very expensive) open your mind with a glass. But be careful as this is not a sippin' drink for a quiet evening in with the cat and slippers.
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Fri, November 9, 2007 - 8:26 AMOne group is enough (unless you are advertising, then spam away).
----
"I have long been sceptical of being told that pre-ban absinthe has no thujone / low thujone by the new manufacturers"
Yet KoSG and Century are not created using pre-ban methods.
----
"Are the secondaries, so well known during the Belle Epoque"
I'm curious where the secondaries as we know them were "so well known" during the Belle Epoque?
Everything I have read shows the belle epoque secondaries as violent hallucinations and fits that consume a person (oddly like a poisoning) not some sort of lucid drunk. The few quotes that point to the romantic happy hallucinations are anachronisms.
----
"I do not think this is the case with thujone in alcohol."
But did you actually control for placebo?
----
"What if Dr Niels Arnold's estimates of 260mg in pre-ban were correct?"
Do you know how he reached said estimates?
Why are his ulterior motives ignored but other people's supposed "commercial interests" payed attention to?
----
Speaking of secondaries and subjective experiences, please explain why many people have secondaries when drinking extremely low thujone absinthe? Why do I have secondaries when drinking <1 mg/l thujone absinthe? -
-
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Fri, November 9, 2007 - 8:50 AM
You have tried one of these high thujone absinthes, Ari? What do you mean by control for the placebo? You mean like float outside my body and watch what was going on? I've tried many very low and many medium thujone absinthes...now I have tried these high thujone absinthes and I can see there is a big difference.
I am interested in knowing what others think as well. Not only you and your crew of merry men have to say. I know what you think, and I also know that you seem to spend every waking hour promoting yoir opinions. Congratulations on getting zero thujone Lucid into America. That is not my interest. Drink what you like, Ari...but don't tell others / mock others for seeking out the new. Be more peaceful and accepting of others my friend.
Dr Niels Arnold has "ulterior motives: now? That's interesting Everyone does that doesn't share your view it seems.
When you say you experience secondaries with <1mg thujone are you not confusing that with an alcohol buzz. I'll ask again (if I may) whether you have actually tried any of these high thujone absinthes? Have you? -
-
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Fri, November 9, 2007 - 9:12 AM"You have tried one of these high thujone absinthes,"
Nope.
----
"What do you mean by control for the placebo? "
I'll take that as a no. By 'controling' an experiment you try to lock down all but one or a few variables so you get useful results. So say you want to test the effects of thujone in absinthe. You would get a group of subjects and a bottle of high and low or no thujone absinthe (tested of course)(even better for the test would to get a single bottle of low to no thujone absinthe and dose half the drinks with thujone). Thus the only variable is thujone. You would then give them to your test subjects in a hidden manner so they don't know what is what, and would test them in a number of ways.
Once that is done you would compare the amount of thujone in your "high" Category with the amount found in traditional absinthe.
So far everyone I've seen who says "I drank absinthe and had secondaries because of the high thujone" is running off baseless assumptions.
-----
"Congratulations on getting zero thujone Lucid into America."
Don't you have a blog to post in?
(Since you have been away, more than just Lucid are sold in the US now.)
-----
"but don't tell others / mock others for seeking out the new."
Never did. I will however mock people who appear to be here using questionable claims that feed on ignorance to advertise products.
----
"Dr Niels Arnold has "ulterior motives: now?"
You didn't actually answer how he got his numbers. But yes, if people like Lachy have ulterior motives then Arnold certainly did as his thesis for the 1989 Sci-Am paper was that Van Gogh drank too much thujone. Obviously absinthe would need to have massive amounts of thujone for his thesis to stand, in which case it would technically be in his best interest to provide a high estimate.
----
"When you say you experience secondaries with <1mg thujone are you not confusing that with an alcohol buzz."
Nope I'm not.
But I will find it interesting if you try and dismiss the subjective experience of a large number of drinkers because they don't match your preconceived notions based on subjective experience.
I would also like to know, if this effect you describe was experienced by pre-ban drinkers, A) where is the evidence of said experience and B) why aren't any of these bottles made using traditional methods and recipes?
-
-
-
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Fri, November 9, 2007 - 11:38 PMWhat would account for a very popular ( for the last 14 years) HG absinthe producing strong excitatory effects in those who consume it. Personally, I have never found a comercial brand that produces this effect. More than six times and according to my teacher who is associated with the gent who makes it MANY more times than the six I have witnessed, those with a history of seizure and even those who are on epilepsy medicine go into seizure when they drink this product. Even people who had seizures in early childhood experience this while no one who does not have this condition or history experiences this. I assumed because of the immense quantity of wormwood used it was because of the thujone but since the taste is so smooth and because it (thujone) is said to be so toxic and/or totally inactive what else could account for the reliable results both positive and negative that have been observed by countless of us on the west coast for well over a decade? Any guesses? -
-
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Sat, November 10, 2007 - 5:53 AMIt generally takes a pretty massive dose of thujone to cause seizures (compared to what is found in normal absinthe) especially since alcohol appears to protect from thujone poisoning.
Knowing nothing about the creations you are talking about I would guess that something else is causing the effects or they are being over exaggerated or the HG products are being dosed. None of the HG producers I know of have every reported such experiences.
-
Unsu...
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Mon, November 12, 2007 - 12:19 PMI've heard of so many foul soak+filter+filter+filter etc. concoctions, it seems people pass off "absinthe" that is far from the real deal that would have many strong effects. Some might say they're just looking for a "party" but some results might be more correctly classified as "poison." [sigh...]
Properly distilled absinthe-- even those with lots and lots of wormwood-- should not induce seizure. I'd suspect "the gent" uses extracts. -
-
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Tue, November 13, 2007 - 4:39 AMPost still soaking using Atremsisia absinthium is the new thing, isn't it? That's not just for colouration either. Vallon started it and another one followed.
Several HG'ers have independently confirmed the effect descibed above. This is actually the basis of my curiosity as some of these folks have a mind blowing knowledge of herbals that leaves us all far behind.
An HG'er using an extract....I don't think so! That would be contary to my opinion of that community. Didn't Dr Dirk L report 62mg/l after a 6 month maceration? I think he did. What happens then if you know your herbs? Storage, cultivation, terroir, drying, climatic conditions and the parts of the plant directly influence the thujone levels in Artemisia absinthium. It is not difficult to see how someone with skill - maybe a true resurrection of a Belle Epoque artisan - could produce an absinthe with a profound thujone level. Is it operating like a ménage à trois with the other two herbals? Could it even be -stretching the analogy - a full scale herbal orgy? This is a question which remains unanswered.
For the record I am not totally dismissing Ted Breaux's concept of the herbal speedball. This is an idea which is worthy of greater exploration. One thing seems clear...without thujone you are staying put at Cape Canaveral, or as someone put it in the papers recently "absinthe without thujone is like Playboy magazine without pictures" -
-
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Tue, November 13, 2007 - 6:44 AM•HGers aren't magical, it only means "home made" nothing more. There isn't a single or specific "HG community"
•Unless those several HGers actually did scientific testing they are stuck guessing that it's thujone based on outdated (and wrong) evidence, just like you.
•62 mg/l is not amazing.
•When did the "belle epoque artisans" skip distillation (as well as aging and drying)?
•One thing is clear, you have no evidence to support your claims that thujone matters but seem to be pushing it for some reason. Apparently you are going to dismiss the many subjective reports of secondaries because they don't fit your preconceived notions.
-
-
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Tue, November 13, 2007 - 10:06 PMNo, this is distilled with mastery! For those with an educated palate it is always ranked among the best out of dozens of international brands.
It never produces seizures in people without a history of it but people with epilepsy or even a history of seizures immediately have it triggered by drinking a couple of glasses.
I believe him that he does not use oil mixes. My parents introduced me to him a LONG time ago and he is very well known in the wine industry in the pacific northwest. This guy had been distilling absinthe for fourteen years and has a lot of experience before that. I was just wondering what could trigger seizures so predictably in people (and ONLY in people) with a history of seizures.
I asked him if it could be the beta asarone in the calamus but he sais that could not be the case.
Just wondering.
BTW. I do get an effect different from alcohol. It feels like a sensory stimulant and increases excitability. I like it. -
-
Unsu...
Seizures? No.
Wed, November 14, 2007 - 3:40 PMMastery according to whom? I'm curious who are these "those" and which are the "dozens of international brands" because if any of those brands had a similar effect, they'd be put out of business. I haven't even heard of crapsinth inducing seizures, and they're loaded up with unfiltered, undistilled herbs. Seizures are absolutely NOT ok and not part of any absinthe experience I've ever heard of. -
-
Re: Seizures? No.
Wed, November 14, 2007 - 3:59 PMExactly. It would be interesting to know what he uses and how he makes it, as I doubt it's traditional.
The closest I can think of is the guy who drank pure wormwood extract and ended up in the hospital.
Speaking of which, I should point out that instead of buying these low thujone absinth products (100 mg is still low btw) pure wormwood extract and thujone is absolutely legal in the US and is sold in stores for a fraction of the cost. It seems silly to buy "high thujone" absinthe if all you care about is the thujone. (disclaimer, you shouldn't actually drink the stuff, this is for information purposes only, and no that's not a "wink wink, nudge nudge" kind of comment).
-
What can trigger a seizure?
Wed, November 14, 2007 - 4:41 PMwow. you sound grumpy. It doesn't sound like you are able to answer the question I put forth so I will inquire with more educated and personable people. BTW, the taste and quality is comparable. I have not heard of epileptics being triggered by any of the commercial brands. It would make sense though if you look at the nature of the drugs taken to block seizures. It is a totally different matter when speaking about people who have no history vs. speaking of those who do have a history of convulsive episodes. For example, there is a warning that certian video games and strobe lights can induce seizure but I could take a room full of people who are not susceptible and expose them for hours and conclude that the warning is wrong. This is like saying that cigarettes can't cause low birth weight because no man I know that smokes has ever delivered a skinny baby. Since myself and many others over the course of fourteen years have observed this phenomenon on a number of occasions I will not conclude that it is imaginary simply because it is not "ok" with someone. Again, I am wondering what would account for this very repeatable phenomenon. -
-
Re: What can trigger a seizure?
Wed, November 14, 2007 - 4:43 PMto clarify, it is the salsa guy that sounds grumpy. I find that ari has an open and scientific mind and has the qualifications to hypothisize as to what would produce this effect. -
-
Unsu...
Re: What can trigger a seizure?
Thu, November 15, 2007 - 12:09 PMI'm "grumpy" because the account of seizures is so troubling.
I would advise against anybody drinking such a concoction, and I call shenanigans on the preparer's expertise.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: Thujone in Absinthe
Thu, September 11, 2008 - 6:37 AMthujone free sinthe sucks ...
distill your own with a high thujone concentration ... you will be happy you did .